LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Run America like business? Check out record with HCA
by MICHAEL L. REYNOLDS, Rome
Sep 18, 2012 | 3855 views | 19 19 comments | 19 19 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MITT ROMNEY OWNS an interest in Redmond Regional Hospital, according to the Aug. 14 New York Times. His company, Bain Capital, controls Hospital Corporation of America, a network of 163 for-profit hospitals in the United States, including our very own Redmond Regional.

Mitt’s presidential run is based on his business experience; he says he will run America just like he ran his company, Bain Capital.

What business is Mitt in? Bain Capital does not manufacture goods or provide services that create productive assets in the United States. No, Bain extracts existing wealth from businesses and communities redistributing it to wealthy investors.

The Times describes how Bain Capital put together a deal with Merrill Lynch and private equity firm, KKR, to purchase Hospital Corporation of America for $33 billion in 2006. Bain, Merrill, and KKR bought HCA with a down payment of $1.2 billion each, borrowed $16 billion using HCA assets as collateral, and assumed $11 billion of HCA debt. Bain collected millions in fees and commissions, out of the borrowed funds, for brokering the sale to itself.

By 2010, Bain’s staff reductions, cost cutting, and aggressive billing of Medicare/Medicaid had substantially increased profits. HCA borrowed more money, which the board voted to pay as dividends to Bain, Merrill, and KKR. Each firm received $1 billion.

In 2011, Bain took HCA public again. The three original investors each cashed out $500 million worth of stock. Bain and KKR still hold $4.8 billion in HCA stock. It is possible they will see a 350 percent return on their original $1.2 billion investment.

There must be new, living wage jobs, improved outcomes in patient health, and efficiency gains if the market rewarded Mitt’s efforts so handsomely. How else could profits have risen so much, so rapidly?

Answer: Bain came up with three ways to get more revenue out of middle class working families, Medicare, Medicaid, private insurers, and HCA.

HCA began to manage its Emergency Rooms for “patient acquisition.” To attract patients, HCA used billboards with ‘wait time stopwatches’ displayed on them. (Sound familiar?) Between 2007 and 2011, Emergency Room visits at HCA hospitals increased 20 percent.

In 2008, HCA changed the system of ‘classifications’ for patients accepted for treatment in its Emergency Rooms. Suddenly, they were all sicker. This allowed HCA to perform more tests and bill Medicare higher charges. In the first quarter of 2009, HCA reported a profit increase of $100 million over the previous quarter.

Finally, Bain instructed HCA to “right-size” hospital-wide medical staffing using computer programs to project patient loads and then set the minimum number and type of staff. HCA nurses and physicians repeatedly voiced concerns about the negative impact of staffing reductions on patient care.

Bed sores, which can cause serious infection and deterioration in health, are relatively easy to prevent with adequate levels of professional staff. For years, HCA has had a poor record of avoidable bedsores. Eight of the 15 worst hospitals for bedsores in the United States are owned by HCA.

Under Bain, HCA’s corporate debt, not its assets, more than doubled, and HCA increased health costs for individuals, Medicare, Medicaid, and private insurers.

There is no evidence Bain’s policies improved quality of care and considerable evidence it placed HCA physicians and nurses in positions of choosing between their jobs and patient treatment. But it has extracted money, lots of money, from Medicare/Medicaid (taxpayers) and American business for a few very wealthy Bain investors.

Bain will muscle up to the public trough one last time when it sells the debt-laden FICA stock before its price plummets when another Medicare/Medicaid billing investigation begins. Then, Mitt and friends will walk away from a hollowed out public institution built over decades by the co-operative work of thousands of Americans; protected by our legal system; and staffed by our public schools and universities.

Mitt says he will run the country like a business. If his stewardship of HCA is an indicator, Mitt and his friends will run the country to extract maximum wealth from working people and the government for the private benefit of a very few billionaires. The voucherization of Medicare is only the beginning.

Comments
(19)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
LiedToAgainAndAgain
|
September 20, 2012
Chief of the Neanderthals, the first community organizer, ordered all of the cave dwellers to pool their meat, furs and resources together for the common good.

"We share...We be all alike. Is good thing," said Chief Bullcrack Obottom. "Trust me on this one."

Villagers said, "Trust him! He descended from Gods from darkest cave, the legendary Black Hole in Sky."

So they trusted him.

End result, best hunters stopped seriously hunting. Best gatherers stopped foraging. Why hunt and forage for yourself when others do it for you?

Result...Extinction.

If Obama is the answer, I don't want to hear the question.

RyanM
|
September 22, 2012
...and this is why I love the RNT opinion section. Never thought I'd see someone argue against civilization.

Next we'll be having an online debate about how useless computers have turned out to be.
Trelicious
|
September 22, 2012
If civilization is defined as: Those who work and produce shall have the fruits of their productivity taken from them and given to those who do not work and do not produce; those who do not produce or work shall vote for leaders who promise to take more from the productive and give it to the non-productive; every four years the non-productive can vote for the percentage of plunder they desire.

Then yeah, I'm agin' it.
RyanM
|
September 23, 2012
Yep that would be a crappy civilization alright.
LiedToAgainAndAgain
|
September 19, 2012
Colonial Jamestown was the first time that American's had to jointly share together in order for the colony to survive. What Obama forgets is the statement that came along with it by Captain John Smith...."If you don't work, you don't eat!"

Evidently Barrack Obama is no John Smith!

If Obama is the answer, I don't want to hear the question,
Gilliplix
|
September 19, 2012
Clearly, HCA is focused on profit, not patient care. Granted, insurance companies and other healthcare organizations are just as guilty.
rhuidean07
|
September 18, 2012
LiedToAgainAndAgain,

You are one angry dude....I wonder how you're gonna cope when President Obama is reelected by a large margin.

Rhuidean
Enforcer
|
September 21, 2012
Well rhuidean07 he will just cope like we have for the last 4 years. We will see many more broken promises and lies, the deficit will continue to rise due to Obama's idiotic spending, employment will continue to rise, America's security from attacks will continue to go down, gas prices will continue to rise, and the rest of the world will continue to laugh at us for re-electing a complete and proven failure. I hope that answered your question.
LiedToAgainAndAgain
|
September 18, 2012
Obama:

1. Promised to repeal The Patriot Act, and then resigned it back into law each year.

2. Promised to do away with Gitmo...4 years later, it's still there.

3. Promised to bring our troops quickly home...still waiting....until AFTER the election 4 years later.

4. Promised to end lobbying in the White House, and then had countless lobbyist to use the White House like a second home.

5. Promised to be transparent, and then immediately had backroom deal after backroom deal involving payoffs and shady deals in order to ram through his Obamacare.

6. Promised to be a uniter, and then IMMEDIATELY told the Republicans, "I won you lost..sit in the back of the bus and shut up...I'm driving."

7. Promised to be a different kind of President, and didn't meet with the Republican minority leaders of the House and the Senate FOR OVER TWO YEARS! Yikes! Our nation in economic crisis mode, and HE DOESN'T EVEN MEET with the opposition! Very telling, about this man!

8. Promised to focus on the economy and jobs "like a laser" from the start, and turned around and spent the first two years doing anything BUT focus on job creation.

And the list could go on and on and on....

If Obama is the answer, I don't want to hear the question.

LiedToAgainAndAgain
|
September 18, 2012
I wonder which fairy tale character President Obama pictured himself in?

Four options:

1. Was he the Pied Piper of Chicago? Possibility....After all, he's got millions of mindless government-dependent Democrats trotting blindly behind him...laughing gaily without a single brain cell in their heads.

2. Perhaps he was the idiot that decided it was best to eat the goose that laid the golden egg? "Share the wealth, my friends!" shouts he with glee, as the last morsel of self-earned income quickly disappears in his vision of America.

3. Maybe he believes that by selling the milk cow for a handful of beans is a good idea? Hey, it worked for Jack, after all!

4. Maybe he dreamed of Michelle in a golden wig, going into a private citizens home and eating and sleeping in their beds? When awakened, he yelled at the bears, "You didn't build that! Someone else built this bed and put the food on the table for you!"

One things for sure...If Obama is the ANSWER...I don't want to hear the question!
appalucy
|
September 18, 2012
So, if we don't run government like a business with REAL checks and balances, what do we get? Trillions in debt, higher taxes and more government control. A audits of the Fed should also be mandatory, don't spend more than you take it in, require a balanced budget (no more kicking the can down the road) and evaluate all employees and their productivity. Some businesses are run better than others, but it sure beats how our Federal Government is currently being run, both in the White House and in Congress.
RyanM
|
September 18, 2012
I would be interested in an educated response to this letter, as I think it points out some of the major problems with laissez faire capitalism.
FormerRoman
|
September 18, 2012
Ryan, If businesses didn't make money-Who would have a Job?
RyanM
|
September 18, 2012
Where did that question come from? Do you think the argument of the letter writer, or myself, is that business shouldn't be allowed to make money?
SqueakyWheel
|
September 21, 2012
You'll never find an educated response here, Ryan. Better just give it up.
Icarus10
|
September 18, 2012
It is amazing considering 99% of the letters are written like a chimp in the first grade. Take a look at the letter entitled "Obama wants to be US dictator." Why print something that stupid?
RyanM
|
September 18, 2012
Wow, that's a well written letter. The structure and organization alone is very uncharacteristic of the usual RNT opinion letter. Well done.
FormerRoman
|
September 18, 2012
Guy sounds like a former "Preacher".
acct101
|
September 18, 2012
FR, The Floyd Co Democratic Party blog has several posts of his this calendar year. His letters to the editor on the Rome News over the past couple of years mirror the Party line.
Postings are not edited and are the responsibility of the author. You agree not to post comments that are abusive, threatening or obscene. Postings may be removed at our discretion.